Soden, B. J., and J. R. Lanzante, 1996: An assessment of satellite and radiosonde climatologies of upper-tropospheric water vapor. Journal of Climate, 9(6), 1235-1250.
Abstract: This study compares radiosonde and satellite climatologies
of upper-tropospheric water vapor for the period 1979-1991. Comparison
of the two climatologies reveals significant differences in the regional
distribution of upper-tropospheric relative humidity. These discrepancies
exhibit a distinct geopolitical dependence that is demonstrated to result
from international differences in radiosonde instrumentation. Specifically,
radiosondes equipped with goldbeater's skin humidity sensors (found primarily
in the former Soviet Union, China, and eastern Europe) report a systematically
moister upper troposphere relative to the satellite observations, whereas
radiosondes equipped with capacitive or carbon hygristor sensors (found
at most other locations) report a systematically drier upper troposphere.
The bias between humidity sensors is roughly 15%-20% in terms of the relative
humidity, being slightly greater during summer than during winter and greater
in the upper troposphere than in the midtroposphere. However, once the
instrumentation bias is accounted for, regional variations of satellite
and radiosonde upper-tropospheric relative humidity are shown to be in
good agreement. Additionally, temporal variations in radiosonde upper-tropospheric
humidity agree reasonably well with the satellite observations and exhibit
much less dependence upon instrumentation.
The impact that the limited spatial coverage of the radiosonde network
has upon the moisture climatology is also examined and found to introduce
systematic errors of 10%-20% relative humidity over data-sparse regions
of the Tropics. It is further suggested that the present radiosonde network
lacks sufficient coverage in the eastern tropical Pacific to adequately
capture ENSO-related variations in upper-tropospheric moisture. Finally,
we investigate the impact of the clear-sky sampling restriction upon the
satellite moisture climatology. Comparison of clear-sky and total-sky radiosonde
observations suggests the clear-sky sampling limitation introduces a modest
dry bias (<10% relative humidity) in the satellite
climatology.